Want to see SBS full AI Analyst Report?
Companhia De Saneamento (SBS) Risk Analysis
Risk Overview Q4, 2021
Risk Change Over Time
No filing history is available.
- Debt & Financing - Risk 1We are owed some substantial unpaid debts. We cannot assure you as to when or whether we will be paid.
Historically, the State and some State entities have delayed payment of substantial amounts owed to us related to water and sewage services. As of December 31, 2021, the State owed us R$76.6 million for water and sewage services. Additionally, the State also owes us substantial amounts related to reimbursements of state-mandated special retirement and pension payments that we make to some of our former employees for which the State is required to reimburse us. With respect to payment of pensions on behalf of the State, we had a contested credit amount of R$1,375.1 million as of December 31, 2021. We do not record this contested amount as a reimbursement credit for actuarial liability due to the uncertainty of payment by the State. We also had an uncontested credit amounting to R$741.9 million which is recorded as related-party receivables. See note 11(a) to our 2021 financial statements. In addition, as of December 31, 2021, we had a provision for an actuarial liability in the amount of R$2,192.1 million with respect to future supplemental pension payments for which the State does not accept responsibility. In addition, certain Municipalities and other government entities also owe us payments. See "-Risks Relating to Our Business- We may face difficulties in collecting overdue amounts owed to us by municipal government entities." We cannot assure you when or if the State and such Municipalities will pay the contested credit amounts, which are still under discussion, and the remaining overdue amounts they owe us. The amounts owed to us by the State, Municipalities and other government entities for water and sewage services and reimbursements for pensions paid may increase in the future.
Risk Highlights Q4, 2021
Risk Word Cloud
Risk Factors Full Breakdown - Total Risks 39
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 1We are controlled by the State of São Paulo, whose interests may differ from the interests of non-controlling shareholders, including holders of ADSs.
As the São Paulo state government owns the majority of our common shares, it is able to control the election of a majority of the members of our Board of Directors and appoint our senior management and with that determine our operating policies and strategy. As of December 31, 2021, the State owned 50.3% of our outstanding common shares. In addition, pursuant to the State Constitution of São Paulo, the Governor of São Paulo, the legal representative of our controlling shareholder, is the competent authority to make these decisions. Both through its control of our Board of Directors as well as by enacting State decrees, the State has in the past directed our company to engage in business activities and make expenditures that promoted political, economic or social goals, that did not necessarily enhance business, financial condition or results of operations. For example, the State issued Decree No. 64,879/2020 in March 2020 setting out emergency measures as a result of the coronavirus outbreak, including exempting customers under the "Residential Social" and "Residential Favela" categories from paying water and sewage bills for all Municipalities we serve. This exemption was extended until September 15, 2020. The São Paulo state government may direct our company to act in this manner again in the future, depending on the evolution of the pandemic in the State of São Paulo. These decisions by the State may not be in the interests of our non-controlling shareholders, including holders of ADs. The State of São Paulo has the power to appoint up to 9 out of the 11 members of our Board of Directors and, through them, influence the choice of a majority of the executive officers responsible for our day-to-day management. Consequently, the State is empowered to approve most matters prescribed by law. We cannot guarantee that there will not be changes to our Board of Directors or Executive Officers and whether such changes may have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition or results of operations, especially during new elections periods.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 2Our controlling shareholder is currently discussing proposals for our corporate reorganization. We cannot guarantee that any potential reorganization will not have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition or results of operations.
On September 29, 2021, the State Privatization Program's Board (Conselho Diretor do Programa Estadual de Desestatização - CDPED), which has authority over our corporate reorganization plan, in view of the New Sanitation Regulatory Framework (Federal Law No. 14,026/2020), as well as State Law No. 17,383/2021, which established the Regional Unit for Drinking Water Supply and Sewage Services for the State of São Paulo, unanimously resolved: (i) to recommend the hiring by the Treasury and Planning Secretariat (Secretaria da Fazenda e Planejamento do Estado de São Paulo), of the International Finance Corporation – IFC, to provide consulting services to the State, consisting in the identification and analysis of possible alternatives for restructuring our share capital; and (ii) at each relevant stage of the work to be carried out by the IFC, the matter should return to the CDPED for evaluation and continuation. As of the date of this annual report, a decision has not been made on the model for our potential corporate reorganization. Also, election for state governor will be held in 2022 which lead to further uncertainty about any future plans for our corporate reorganization. We cannot assure that CDPED will give us guidance on our potential corporate reorganization, the terms of such guidance, or that any potential reorganization will not have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition or results of operation. See "-Regulatory Risks-Current regulatory uncertainty, especially with regard to the New Legal Framework for Basic Sanitation, may have an adverse effect on our business, financial condition or results of operations."
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 3Our right to withdraw water from the Guarapiranga and Billings reservoirs is being challenged judicially by minority shareholders of EMAE.
We withdraw water for use in the São Paulo metropolitan region from the Guarapiranga and Billings reservoirs. Empresa Metropolitana de Águas e Energia S.A., or EMAE, a company that is also controlled by the State of São Paulo, has a concession to produce hydroelectric energy using water from the same reservoirs. EMAE commenced various lawsuits against us in the past seeking compensation for the water we withdraw from these reservoirs. Those lawsuits have now been settled by way of an agreement between EMAE and our company. However, on April 11, 2016, we were also named in a separate lawsuit filed by minority shareholders of EMAE against the State of São Paulo, as controlling shareholder of EMAE. The minority shareholders are seeking an order to require the State to stop us from withdrawing water from the reservoirs without paying compensation to EMAE, and to allow EMAE to pump water from the reservoirs for its hydroelectric facility. The plaintiffs allege that the State, in its capacity as controlling shareholder of EMAE, has acted unduly to EMAE's detriment and in favor of our company. This lawsuit was dismissed and is currently under appeal by the plaintiffs. In addition, on August 7, 2017 we were named in a new lawsuit against us, EMAE and the National Electric Energy Agency (Agência Nacional de Energia Elétrica, or ANEEL), brought by Alvaro Luiz de Lima de Alvares Otero, another minority shareholder of EMAE, requesting the annulment of ANEEL's order approving the settlement agreement mentioned above, as well as our condemnation for indemnifying EMAE for damages suffered by EMAE. The plaintiff alleges that the order is illegal and harmful, jeopardizing the operational viability of the Henry Borden hydroelectric power plant, as well as the energy security of the State of São Paulo, the Southeast region of Brazil and Brazil as a whole. The judge dismissed this lawsuit without judgment on the merits, but this decision is currently being appealed. The settlement agreement between EMAE and us does not necessarily terminate the separate lawsuits. If one of the ongoing lawsuits by minority shareholders of EMAE requires the State to make a different decision regarding water use from what was agreed between EMAE and the State of São Paulo, our ability to withdraw water from the Guarapiranga and Billings reservoirs may be compromised. If we were no longer able to withdraw water from these reservoirs, we would have to transport water from locations further away, which would increase our water transportation costs and may affect our ability to provide adequate service in the region, which may have an adverse effect on our financial condition and results of operations. In addition, we may be ordered to pay any indemnity to EMAE if the agreement is judicially invalidated, which could have material adverse effects on our financial condition and operating results. See "Item 7. Major Shareholders and Related Party Transactions."
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 4Any sale of our shares to the private sector which removes the State as our majority shareholder brings uncertainties regarding the maintenance of current program contracts.
The New Legal Framework for Basic Sanitation establishes that, in the event of the sale of the State's share control to the private sector, the current program contracts may be replaced with new concession contracts, subject to the State Privatization Program, where applicable. The framework also establishes that if there is a change in the clauses of these program contracts, such proposals must be presented to the public entities holding the service, who must, within 180 days, manifest their opinion if in disagreement, after which the proposal will be considered as approved. However, prior approval by the public entities that executed the contract related to the program is only required if the majority shareholder requests an amendment to the term, purpose or certain other sections of the contract at the time of the change of control. Regardless of that, most of our contracts have a termination clause in the event of a change in our control. We cannot assure you that all the public entities holding the service will agree to any proposed amendments to the contracts and that the result of those negotiations would not have a material impact on our revenues or operations.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 5The relative volatility and illiquidity of the Brazilian securities markets may substantially limit your ability to sell our common shares underlying the ADSs at the price and time you desire.
Investing in securities from emerging markets such as Brazil involves greater risk than investing in securities of issuers in major securities markets, and these investments are often considered to be more speculative in nature. The Brazilian securities market is substantially smaller, less liquid, more concentrated and can be more volatile than major securities markets. Accordingly, although you are entitled to withdraw the common shares underlying the ADSs from the depositary at any time, your ability to sell the common shares underlying the ADSs at a price and time at which you wish to do so may be substantially limited. There is also significantly greater concentration in the Brazilian securities market than in major securities markets. The ten largest companies in terms of market capitalization represented approximately 42.6% of the aggregate market capitalization of the B3 as of December 31, 2021.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 6Investors who exchange ADSs for common shares may lose their ability to remit foreign currency abroad and obtain Brazilian tax advantages.
The Brazilian custodian for the common shares underlying our ADSs must obtain a certificate of registration from the Central Bank in order to be entitled to remit U.S. dollars abroad for payments of dividends and other distributions relating to our common shares or upon sales of our common shares. If an ADR holder decides to exchange ADSs for the underlying common shares, the holder will be entitled to continue to rely on the custodian's certificate of registration for five business days from the date of exchange. After that period, the holder may not be able to obtain and remit U.S. dollars abroad upon sale of our common shares, or distributions relating to our common shares, unless he or she obtains his or her own certificate of registration or registers the investment under CMN Resolution No. 4,373/2014, dated September 29, 2014, (the "4,373 Holder") which entitles registered foreign investors to buy and sell on a Brazilian stock exchange. If the holder does not obtain a certificate of registration or register under Resolution No. 4,373/2014, the holder will generally be subject to less favorable tax treatment on gains with respect to our common shares. If a holder attempts to obtain his or her own certificate of registration, the holder may incur expenses or suffer delays in the application process, which could delay his or her ability to receive dividends or distributions relating to our common shares or the return of his or her capital in a timely manner. The custodian's certificate of registration or any foreign capital registration obtained by a holder may be affected by future legislative changes, and additional restrictions applicable to the holder, the disposition of the underlying common shares or the repatriation of the proceeds of disposition may be imposed in the future. Further, during the 2018 presidential campaign, the then main contender and current Minister of Economy proposed taxing dividends paid by Brazilian companies and changes in taxation method of interest on equity. If this campaign promise were to be realized, this would increase the tax expenses associated with any dividend, interest on equity or distributions made by Brazilian companies, which could impact us or our shareholders and the value of our common shares and ADSs. Uncertainty regarding the implementation by the current government of related changes in monetary, fiscal and pension policies, as well as pertinent legislation, could contribute to economic instability. These uncertainties and new measures could increase the volatility of Brazilian securities markets.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 7A holder of common shares or ADSs may face difficulties in protecting his or her interests as a shareholder because we are a Brazilian mixed capital company.
We are a mixed capital company (sociedade de economia mista) organized under the laws of Brazil, and all of our directors and officers and our controlling shareholder reside in Brazil. All of our assets are located in Brazil. As a result, it may not be possible for a holder to effect service of process upon us or these other persons within the United States or other jurisdictions outside Brazil or to enforce against us or these other persons judgments obtained in the United States or other jurisdictions outside Brazil. Because judgments of U.S. courts for civil liabilities based upon the U.S. federal securities laws may only be enforced in Brazil if certain requirements are met, a holder may face more difficulty in protecting his or her interests in the case of actions by our directors, officers or our controlling shareholder than would shareholders of a corporation incorporated in a state or other jurisdiction of the United States. In addition, under Brazilian law, none of our assets which are essential to our ability to render public services are subject to seizure or attachment. Furthermore, the execution of a judgment against our controlling shareholder may be delayed, since the State may only be able to pay a judgment if it is provided for in its budget in a subsequent fiscal year. None of the public property of our controlling shareholder is available for seizure or attachment, either prior to or after judgment.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 8Mandatory arbitration provisions in our bylaws may limit the ability of a holder of our ADSs to enforce liability under U.S. securities laws.
Under our bylaws, any disputes among us, our shareholders and our management with respect to the Novo Mercado rules, the Brazilian Corporate Law and Brazilian capital markets regulations will be resolved by arbitration conducted pursuant to the B3 Arbitration Rules in the Market Arbitration Chamber. Any disputes among shareholders and ADR holders, and any disputes between us and our shareholders and ADR holders, will also be submitted to arbitration. As a result, a court in the United States might require that a claim brought by an ADR holder predicated upon the U.S. securities laws be submitted to arbitration in accordance with our bylaws. In that event, a purchaser of ADSs would be effectively precluded from pursuing remedies under the U.S. securities laws in the U.S. courts. However, a court in the United States could allow claims predicated upon the U.S. securities laws brought by holders who purchased ADSs on the NYSE to be submitted to U.S. courts.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 9A holder of our common shares and ADSs might be unable to exercise preemptive rights and tag-along rights with respect to the common shares.
U.S. holders of common shares and ADSs may not be able to exercise the preemptive rights and tag-along rights relating to common shares unless a registration statement under the U.S. Securities Act of 1933, as amended, or the Securities Act, is effective with respect to those rights or an exemption from the registration requirements of the Securities Act is available. We are not obligated to file a registration statement with respect to our common shares relating to these rights, and we cannot assure you that we will file any such registration statement. Unless we file a registration statement or an exemption from registration is available, an ADR holder may receive only the net proceeds from the sale of his or her preemptive rights and tag-along rights or, if these rights cannot be sold, they will lapse and the ADR holder will receive no value for them.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 10Holders of our ADSs do not have the same voting rights as our shareholders.
Holders of our ADSs do not have the same voting rights as holders of our shares. Holders of our ADSs are entitled to the contractual rights set forth for their benefit under the deposit agreements. ADS holders exercise voting rights by providing instructions to the depositary, as opposed to attending shareholders meetings or voting by other means available to shareholders. In practice, the ability of a holder of ADSs to instruct the depositary as to voting will depend on the timing and procedures for providing instructions to the depositary, either directly or through the holder's custodian and clearing system. The deposit agreement also provides that if the depositary does not receive any instructions from a holder of ADRs, the ADR holder may be deemed to have given a discretionary proxy to a person designated by our company and the underlying shares may be voted by such person. However, we have chosen not to designate any person to exercise these deemed proxy rights with respect to any annual or special general meetings, and ADSs for which no specific voting instructions were received by the Depositary were therefore not voted at that meeting.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 11If we issue new shares or our shareholders sell shares in the future, the market price of your ADS may be reduced.
Sales of a substantial number of shares, or the belief that this may occur, could decrease the prevailing market price of our common and preferred shares and ADS by diluting the shares' value. If we issue new shares or our existing shareholders sell shares they hold, the market price of our common and preferred shares, and of the ADS, may decrease significantly. Such issuances and sales also might make it more difficult for us to issue shares or ADS in the future at a time and a price that we deem appropriate and for you to sell your securities at or above the price you paid for them. Our controlling shareholder, the state of São Paulo, may decide to undertake a corporate reorganization, for a variety of reasons which could have the effect of diluting existing shareholders and ADS holders or lead to a change of control. See "-Our controlling shareholder is currently discussing proposals for our corporate reorganization. We cannot guarantee that any potential reorganization will not have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition or results of operations."
See a full breakdown of risk according to category and subcategory. The list starts with the category with the most risk. Click on subcategories to read relevant extracts from the most recent report.