Companhia Energetica Minas Gerais (CID) Risk Analysis
Risk Overview Q4, 2022
Risk Change Over Time
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 1An investor of our common shares or preferred shares and common or preferred ADSs might be unable to exercise preemptive rights and tag-along rights with respect to our shares.
U.S. investors of common shares or preferred shares and common or preferred ADSs may not be able to exercise the preemptive rights and tag-along rights relating to our shares unless a registration statement under the U.S. Securities Act of 1933, as amended, or the Securities Act, is effective with respect to those rights or an exemption from the registration requirements of the Securities Act is available. We are not obligated to file a registration statement with respect to our shares relating to these rights, and we cannot assure that we will file any such registration statement. Unless we file a registration statement or an exemption from registration is available, an ADR investor may receive only the net proceeds from the sale of their preemptive rights and tag-along rights or, if these rights cannot be sold, they will lapse and the ADR investor will receive only the net proceeds from the sale of their preemptive rights and tag-along rights or, if these rights cannot be sold, they will lapse and the ADR holder will receive no value for them.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 2Future equity issuances may dilute the holdings of current holders of our shares or ADSs and could materially affect the market price for those securities.
We may in the future decide to offer additional equity to raise capital or for other purposes. Any such future equity offering could reduce the proportionate ownership and voting interests of holders of our shares and ADSs, as well as our earnings and net equity value per share or ADS. Any offering of shares and ADSs by us or our main shareholders, or a perception that any such offering is imminent, could have an adverse effect on the market price of these securities.
- Corporate Activity and Growth - Risk 3The operating and financial results of our subsidiaries, jointly controlled entities and affiliates, non controlling or from any companies which we may acquire in the future, may negatively affect our strategies, operating results and financial condition.
We own equity in and do business through various subsidiaries and investees, including companies with assets in the energy generation and transmission sectors, energy and natural gas distribution sectors and other related business. The future development of our subsidiaries, jointly controlled entities and affiliates, such as Transmissora Aliança de Energia Elétrica S.A. (‘Taesa') and Aliança Geração de Energia S.A. (‘Aliança'), Guanhães Energia S.A. and Norte Energia S.A. (‘NESA') could have a significant impact on our business and operating results. The Company's ability to meet its financial obligations is correlated, in part, to the cash flow and the profits of its subsidiaries and investees, and the distribution to the Company by such companies of profits in the form of dividends or other advances or payments. If these companies' abilities to generate profits and cash flows are reduced, this may cause a reduction of dividends and interest on capital paid to the Company, which could have a material adverse effect on our results of operations and financial position. In addition, the investees may not achieve the results expected when they were acquired. The process of integration for any acquired business could subject the Company to certain risks, such as, for example, the following: (i) unexpected expenses; (ii) inability to integrate the activities of the companies acquired with a view to obtaining the expected economies of scale and efficiency gains; (iii) possible delays related to integration of the operations of companies; (iv) exposure to potential contingencies; (v) legal claims made against the acquired business that were unknown at the time of its acquisition; (vi)environmental licensing and liabilities, (vii) hydrological risk, (viii) power system operation and control, and (ix) general claims. The Company might be unsuccessful in dealing with these or other risks, or problems related to any other operation of a future acquisition and be negatively affected by the companies acquired or which may be acquired in the future. Furthermore, some of our subsidiaries and investees might, in the future, enter into agreements with creditors that could restrict dividend payments or other transfers of funds to the Company. These subsidiaries are separate legal entities. Any rights that we may have in relation to the receipt of assets or other payments in the event of liquidation or reorganization of any subsidiary, could be structurally subordinated to the demands of the creditors of such subsidiary (including tax authorities, commercial creditors and lenders to those subsidiaries). Any deterioration in the operating results or financial conditions of these subsidiaries, and any sanctions or penalties imposed on them, could have a material adverse effect on the Company's business results of operations or financial condition.
Risk Highlights Q4, 2022
Risk Word Cloud
Risk Factors Full Breakdown - Total Risks 60
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 1We are controlled by the government of the State of Minas Gerais, which might have interests that are different from the interests of our other investors, or even of the Company.
As our controlling shareholder, the government of the State of Minas Gerais exercises substantial influence on the strategic orientation of our business. Currently it holds 51% of the common shares of CEMIG and as majority shareholder has full powers to decide on business relating to the Company's objects as stated in the by-laws, and to adopt whatever decisions it deems to be necessary for the defense of its interests and development. The government of the State of Minas Gerais can elect the majority of our senior management and has the authority to approve, among other subjects, matters that require a qualified quorum of shareholders. The latter include transactions with related parties, shareholding reorganizations and the date and payment of dividends. The government of the State of Minas Gerais, as our controlling shareholder, has the capacity to direct us to engage in activities and to make investments that promote the controlling shareholder's economic or social objectives, and these might not be strictly aligned with the Company's strategy or the strategies of our other shareholders, adversely affecting the direction of our business.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 2Our processes of governance, risk management, compliance and internal controls might fail to avoid regulatory penalties, damages to our reputation, or other adverse effects on our business, results of operations or financial condition.
Our Company is subject to various different regulatory structures, of which the following are examples: (a) laws and regulations of the Brazilian energy sector, such as Law 10,848/04 (on trading in energy) and regulations by ANEEL; (b) the laws and regulations that apply to listed companies with securities traded in the Brazilian capital markets, such as Law 6,404/76 (the ‘Corporate Law') and regulations of the CVM; (c) laws and regulations that apply to Brazilian companies with majority state-owned shareholdings, such as Law 13,303/2016 (the ‘State Companies Law'); (d) laws and regulations that apply to Brazilian companies that have securities registered with the SEC, such as the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) and regulations of the SEC; and (e) laws and regulations regarding privacy and data protection, such as Law 13,709/2018 (the ‘General Data Protection Law, LGPD'), among others. Furthermore, Brazil has rigorous legislation relating to maintaining competition, combat of improbity and preventing corrupt practices. For instance, Law 12,846/13 (the ‘Anticorruption Law') established objective liabilities for Brazilian companies that commit acts against Brazilian or foreign public administration, including acts relating to public bidding processes and administrative contracts, and established tough penalties for those companies that are punished. The Company has a high number of administrative contracts with high values and a large number of suppliers and customers, which increases its exposure to risks of fraud and administrative impropriety. Our Company has structures and policies for the prevention and combat of fraud and corruption, audit and internal controls, and has adopted the recommendations for Best Corporate Governance Practices recommended by the Brazilian Corporate Governance Institute (Instituto Brasileiro de Governança Corporativa, or ‘IBGC') and the framework of the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (‘COSO'). Furthermore, due to the majority interest held by the State Government in our shareholding structure, we are required to contract the greater part of our works, services, advertising,purchases, disposals and rentals, through competitive bidding processes and administrative contracts, which are ruled by the Tenders Law, State Companies Law and other complementary legislation. However, despite the Company having processes of governance, risk management and compliance, we might be unable to avoid future violations of the laws and regulations to which we are subject (regarding labor, tax, environment, energy, among others), or violations of our internal control mechanisms, our Code of Ethics and Code of Professional Conduct, or the occurrence of fraudulent or dishonest behavior by employees, or individuals or legal entities that are contracted, or other agents that may represent the company in dealings with third parties, especially with the Public Authorities.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 3ChangedAn investor of our common shares or preferred shares and common or preferred ADSs might be unable to exercise preemptive rights and tag-along rights with respect to our shares.
U.S. investors of common shares or preferred shares and common or preferred ADSs may not be able to exercise the preemptive rights and tag-along rights relating to our shares unless a registration statement under the U.S. Securities Act of 1933, as amended, or the Securities Act, is effective with respect to those rights or an exemption from the registration requirements of the Securities Act is available. We are not obligated to file a registration statement with respect to our shares relating to these rights, and we cannot assure that we will file any such registration statement. Unless we file a registration statement or an exemption from registration is available, an ADR investor may receive only the net proceeds from the sale of their preemptive rights and tag-along rights or, if these rights cannot be sold, they will lapse and the ADR investor will receive only the net proceeds from the sale of their preemptive rights and tag-along rights or, if these rights cannot be sold, they will lapse and the ADR holder will receive no value for them.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 4ChangedFuture equity issuances may dilute the holdings of current holders of our shares or ADSs and could materially affect the market price for those securities.
We may in the future decide to offer additional equity to raise capital or for other purposes. Any such future equity offering could reduce the proportionate ownership and voting interests of holders of our shares and ADSs, as well as our earnings and net equity value per share or ADS. Any offering of shares and ADSs by us or our main shareholders, or a perception that any such offering is imminent, could have an adverse effect on the market price of these securities.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 5The relative volatility and illiquidity of the Brazilian securities market may adversely affect our shareholders.
Investing in Latin American securities, such as the preferred shares, common shares, preferred ADSs or common ADSs, involves a higher degree of risk than investing in securities of issuers from countries with more stable political and economic environments and such investments are generally considered speculative in nature. These investments are subject to certain economic and political risks, including, as examples, the following: - Changes to the regulatory, tax, economic and political environment that may affect the ability of investors to receive payment, in whole or in part, related to their investments; and - Restrictions on foreign investment and on repatriation of capital invested. The Brazilian securities market is substantially smaller, less liquid, more concentrated and more volatile than the major securities markets in the United States. This might substantially limit an investor's ability to sell the shares underlying his preferred or common ADSs for the desired price and within the desired period. In 2022, the São Paulo Stock Exchange (Brasil, Bolsa, Balcão S.A, or ‘B3'), the only stock exchange in Brazil on which our shares are traded, had an annual market capitalization of R$6.3 trillion, and average daily trading volume of R$25.2 billion.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 6Holders of the preferred and common ADSs, and holders of our shares, may have different shareholders' rights than holders of shares in U.S. companies.
Our corporate governance, disclosure requirements and accounting practices are governed by our by-laws, by the Level 1 Differentiated Corporate Governance Practices Regulations (‘Regulamento de Práticas Diferenciadas de Governança Corporativa Nível 1') of the B3 (the main Brazilian stock exchange) by the Brazilian Corporate Law (Federal Law 6,404/76) and by the rules issued by the CVM. These regulations may differ from the legal principles that would apply if our Company were incorporated in a jurisdiction in the United States, such as Delaware or New York, or in other jurisdictions outside Brazil. In addition, the rights of an ADS holder, which are derived from the rights of holders of our common or preferred shares to have his interests protected in relation to decisions by our board of directors or our controlling shareholder, may be different under the Brazilian Corporate Law from the rules of other jurisdictions. Rules against insider trading and self-dealing and other rules for the preservation of shareholder interests may also be different in Brazil if compared to the United States rules, potentially establishing a disadvantage for holders of the preferred shares, common shares, or preferred or common ADSs.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 7Foreign shareholders may be unable to enforce judgments given in non-Brazilian courts against the Company, or against members of its Board of Directors or Executive Board.
All our directors and officers reside in Brazil. Our assets, as well as the assets of these individuals, are located mostly in Brazil. As a result, it may not be possible for foreign shareholders to effect service of process on them within the United States or other jurisdictions outside Brazil, or to attach their assets, or to enforce against them, or against the Company in United States courts, or in the courts of other jurisdictions outside Brazil, judgments that are predicated upon the civil liability provisions of the securities laws of the United States or the respective laws of such other jurisdictions. In order to have a judgment rendered outside of Brazil enforced in Brazil, the party seeking enforcement would need to be recognized in the courts of Brazil (to the extent that Brazilian courts may have jurisdiction) and such courts would enforce such judgment without any retrial or reexamination of the merits of the original action only if such judgment had been previously ratified by the Superior Court of Justice (Superior Tribunal de Justição, or ‘STJ'), in accordance with Articles 216-A to 216- X of the Internal Regulations of the STJ (RISTJ), introduced by Regulatory Amendments No. 18/2014 and No. 24/2016. Notwithstanding the foregoing, no assurance can be given that ratification will be obtained.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 8Exchange of preferred ADSs or common ADSs for underlying shares may have adverse consequences.
The Brazilian custodian for the preferred shares and common shares must obtain an electronic certificate of foreign capital registration from the Central Bank to remit U.S. dollars from Brazil to other countries for payments of dividends, or any other cash distributions, or to remit the proceeds of a sale of shares. If the investor decides to exchange his preferred ADSs or common ADSs for the underlying shares, the investor will be able to continue to rely, for five business days from the date of the exchange, on the depositary bank's electronic certificate of registration in order to receive any proceeds distributed in connection with the shares. After that period, the investor may not be able to obtain and remit U.S. dollars abroad upon sale of our common/preferred shares, or distributions relating to our common/preferred shares, unless he or she obtains his or her own certificate of registration or registers the investment under CMN Resolution 4,373/2014, dated September 29, 2014, which entitles registered foreign investors (‘Resolution 4,373/2014') to buy and sell on a Brazilian stock exchange. If the investor does not obtain a certificate of registration or register under Resolution 4,373/2014, the investor will generally be subject to less favorable tax treatment on gains with respect to our common shares. If the ADR investors attempt to obtain their own certificate of registration, they may incur expenses or suffer delays in the application process, which could delay their ability to receive dividends or distributions relating to our common shares or the return of their capital in a timely manner. The custodian's certificate of registration or any foreign capital registration obtained by an investor may be affected by future legislative changes, and additional restrictions applicable to the investor, the disposition of the underlying common/preferred shares or the repatriation of the proceeds of disposition may be imposed in the future. If the investors decide to exchange their preferred or common shares back into preferred ADSs or common ADSs, respectively, once they have registered their investment in preferred shares or common shares, they may deposit their preferred or common shares with the custodian and rely on the depositary bank's registration certificate, subject to certain conditions. We cannot guarantee that the depositary bank's certificate of registry or any certificate of foreign capital registration obtained by an investor may not be affected by future legislative or other regulatory changes, nor that additional Brazilian restrictions applicable to the investor, or to the sale of the underlying preferred shares, or to repatriation of the proceeds from the sale, will not be imposed in the future.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 9Judgments of Brazilian courts with respect to our shares will be payable only in Reais.
If proceedings are brought in the courts of Brazil seeking to enforce our obligations in respect of our shares, we will not be required to discharge any such obligations in a currency other than Reais. Under Brazilian exchange control limitations, an obligation in Brazil to pay amounts denominated in a currency other than Reais may only be satisfied in Brazilian currency at the exchange rate, as determined by the Central Bank, in effect on the date the judgment is obtained, and any such amounts are then adjusted to reflect exchange rate variations through the effective payment date. The then prevailing exchange rate may not afford non-Brazilian investors full compensation for any claim arising out of, or related to, our obligations under our shares.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 10Sales of a substantial number of shares, or the perception that such sales might take place, could adversely affect the prevailing market price of our shares, or of the preferred or common ADSs.
As a consequence of the issuance of new shares, sales of shares by existing share investors, or the perception that such a sale might occur, the market price of our shares and, by extension, of the preferred and/or common ADSs, may decrease significantly.
- Share Price & Shareholder Rights - Risk 11The preferred shares and preferred ADSs generally do not have voting rights, and the common ADSs can only be voted by proxy by providing voting instructions to the depositary.
Under the Brazilian Corporate Law and our by-laws, holders of our preferred shares, and, consequently, holders of our ADSs representing preferred shares, are not entitled to vote at our shareholders' meetings, except in very specific circumstances. Holders of our preferred ADSs may also encounter difficulties in the exercise of certain rights, including the limited voting rights. Holders of the ADSs for our common shares do not have automatic entitlement to vote in our General Meetings of Shareholders, other than by power of attorney, by sending a voting instruction to the depositary. Where there is not enough time to send the form with voting instructions to the depository, or in the event of omission to send the voting instruction, the holders of ADSs for CEMIG's preferred and common shares may be unable to vote by means of instructions to the depository.
See a full breakdown of risk according to category and subcategory. The list starts with the category with the most risk. Click on subcategories to read relevant extracts from the most recent report.