A LinkedIn post from Herd Security highlights concerns that overly aggressive phishing simulations may harm security-awareness programs rather than improve them. The post suggests that fear-based scenarios, such as fake payroll delays or HR complaints, can erode employee trust in the security function and fail to measure genuine awareness.
According to the post, Herd Security advocates designing simulations that balance realism with psychological safety, leaving employees better prepared while maintaining trust in internal security teams. The company outlines principles such as matching test difficulty to organizational maturity, using short lessons instead of public call-outs, and running exercises on a rolling cadence.
The post also notes growing relevance of smishing and vishing, indicating that effective programs must extend beyond email to cover SMS and voice channels. For investors, this emphasis on multi-channel training and user-centric design suggests potential differentiation for Herd Security in the crowded cybersecurity awareness market.
By framing guidance around program integrity and employee trust, the content implies a focus on long-term customer value rather than purely punitive testing metrics. This positioning could support retention among enterprise clients seeking sustainable behavior change, potentially strengthening Herd Security’s competitive standing and revenue visibility in security training solutions.


